Critical analysis of a qualitative study

From reviewing the description of methods, few authors provided a description or justification of case study methodology that demonstrated how their study was informed by the methodological literature that exists on this approach.

Get Full Essay Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues. Narrative stories, vignettes, and thick description are used to provoke vicarious experience and a sense of being there with the researcher in their interaction with the case.

Discussion The findings of this study have highlighted a number of issues for researchers. Categories and codes are usually arranged in a tree diagram structure in the analytical framework.

Methodology or method? A critical review of qualitative case study reports

The criteria used to assess the quality of the case studies were a set of qualitative indicators. Of important is the fact that a range of care bundles are present, each differing in its specific care process that focuses on VAP prevention and even mortality when VAP occurs.

In this article we discuss when it is appropriate to use the Framework Method and how it compares to other qualitative analysis methods. The process of transcription is a good opportunity to become immersed in the data and is to be strongly encouraged for new researchers.

Commonly, there appeared to be confusion between case studies and case reports. Case studies in health and social sciences did not provide sufficient information for the reader to understand case selection, and why this case was chosen above others.

Critical analysis of a qualitative study Essay Sample

As any form of qualitative or quantitative analysis is not a purely technical process, but influenced by the characteristics of the researchers and their disciplinary paradigms, critical reflection throughout the research process is paramount, including in the design of the study, the construction or collection of data, and the analysis.

These reports presented data for small samples of no more than three people, places or phenomenon. This does not suggest that case study methodology cannot be multimethod, however, methodology should be consistent in design, be clearly described Meyer, ; Stake,and maintain focus on the case Creswell, b.

Journals in business or education were also excluded, although a review of case studies in international business journals has been published elsewhere Piekkari et al.

The study context was adequately described, providing detail on the general practitioner GP clinics and relevant political and economic influences. Charting involves summarizing the data by category from each transcript.

Critical analysis of a qualitative study Essay Sample

The Framework Method is most commonly used for the thematic analysis of semi-structured interview transcripts, which is what we focus on in this article, although it could, in principle, be adapted for other types of textual data [ 13 ], including documents, such as meeting minutes or diaries [ 12 ], or field notes from observations [ 10 ].

Abstract Background The Framework Method is becoming an increasingly popular approach to the management and analysis of qualitative data in health research. The difference would become apparent in how themes are selected: Using the information submitted in the research article, ICU medical personnel can refine their care plans for increased effectiveness in the reduction of VAP rates in the ICU.

The chart should include references to interesting or illustrative quotations. Case study research can be situated within different paradigms or designed with an array of methods. All articles reviewed contained a description of study methods; however, the length, amount of detail, and position of the description in the article varied.

The study is bounded to 10 general practice clinics in Denmark, who had received federal funding to implement preventative care services based on a Motivational Interviewing intervention.

Generalist health and social science journals were excluded that might have contained good quality case studies. Technical terms are included in the glossary below. This kind of statement is clearly meaningless because the sampling in qualitative research is not designed to be representative of a wider population, but purposive to capture diversity around a phenomenon [ 41 ].

Bundles to Prevent Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia: In this respect, the present research article answers the question of whether there exists one care bundle that would be more effective in reducing the incidence of VAP in the ICU.

Conflict of interest and funding The authors have not received any funding or benefits from industry or elsewhere to conduct this study. There were inconsistencies in methodology and study design, which indicated that researchers were confused whether case study was a methodology or a method.

This paper is a report of an integrative review conducted to critically analyse the contemporary use of qualitative case study methodology in nursing research.Critical Appraisal of Qualitative Research Study Words Feb 3rd, 4 Pages The problem addressed in this study is the fact that nursing home residents are sent to the hospital quite frequently for diagnostic testing and to receive health care services.

Research Critique, Part 1 Prepare a critical analysis of a qualitative study focusing on the problem statement, study purpose, research question, literature review, and theoretical framework. The completed analysis should bewords.  Critical Analysis of a Metasynthesis Qualitative Study Focused on Adult Traumatic Brain Injury Patients Jaime Westfall Grand Canyon University Traumatic Brain Injury Worldwide Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) is a problem that affects humans on every continent where humans have established societies.

 Critical Analysis of a Metasynthesis Qualitative Study Focused on Adult Traumatic Brain Injury Patients Jaime Westfall Grand Canyon University Traumatic Brain Injury Worldwide Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) is a problem that affects humans on every continent where humans have established societies.

According to Levack et al () worldwide there are approximately ten million individuals whose death or. Step-by-step guide to critiquing research. Part 2: qualitative research Abstract As with a quantitative study, critical analysis of a qualitative study involves an in-depth review of how each step of the research was undertaken.

Qualitative and quantitative studies are, however, Critical appraisal n Qualitative research Q. The study is about of nursing student experiences of clinical practice for which qualitative is a suitable design. Identifying the problem which initiated the research should be clearly described early in the report (Ryan-Wenger ).

Critical analysis of a qualitative study
Rated 0/5 based on 31 review